When your art becomes artless


The zone… When I get into the zone I’m insanely great at writing code. If you ask me to explain to you what is C++ I would not be able. I could not “say” a line of C++ code. But when I am in the zone I speak C++ fluently. The code becomes obvious. I can absorb a huge amount of parameters and make the code clean, smooth and efficient.  This also happens when I write in English(which by extension is a special way of writing code).

This happens to every developer, writer, creator. It happens to you in a different kind of art. It could painting, writing, leading your team, accounting, running… you have your art and I’m sure you see what I mean.

When you reach the zone, there is no limit. Your art does not matter actually. You navigate, in an almost meditative state, higher than any of your art’s technical aspects. Your art becomes artless. Your art techniques becomes pointless. It gets done by itself, you are not working on it, you become the art. The product… well it’s just a product.

This is a concept that is largely explained in Zen in the art of archery. In this book Eugen Herrigel talks about his experience as practicing archery in Japan and how he became detached from the technique. The bow, arrow and target didn’t matter anymore. To simplify it to a pop culture analogy: think of it as Luke Skywalker shooting the Death Star with his eyes closed. The real target for the archer is himself. He “hits” himself. After all, aiming at a target is pointless. The arrow hits the target… big deal! But what does it mean?

If you think of your art. What is the ultimate purpose? Once you have reached your goal, nothing really happens except if you were changed in the process. Your art is you not what you do. But for that you have to reach the zone at some point.

It’s even difficult to put into words. Because how can I define that I’m the art when I write? The text seems to be the art but actually it is just me and a laptop in a special moment in a special place where everything is aligned so I can deliver this. That is what matters.

Now how could we extend this state of clarity? Is there a way to let go and be detached that life becomes the artless art? Can we live entirely in this mental state.

Two days ago I read this article about what people regret just before they die. This article mentions the “phenomenal clarity of vision that people gain at the end of their lives”. Probably because there is no goal anymore, no need to act and everything gets detached. The art of life becomes literally artless.

I don’t really understand what it would be.

For now I just continue to write and I stay in the zone… for one more second and then another one until this gets published.

Subscribe by email:

  • http://twitter.com/TimothyChutes Timothy Chutes

    This is actually studied by science and psychology and is referred to as Flow.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_%28psychology%29

    What I find most interesting is that I find that it happens even when doing things that aren’t artful. Even when just browsing the web or doing research, I find myself entering Flow.

    • http://www.inspacewetrust.com Manuel Loigeret

      I voluntarily did not use the word “Flow” because this term has a kind of hype on the web and I do not want to surf on this thing that starts to lost its meaning.
      I feel closer to the definition of the “artless art” which is described in Zen in the art of archery. Through the book the author writes about how he even lost the need of performing its art in the right way. In a sense the practice Kyudo (the japanese archery) is more mystic and spiritual and it is ok to not hit the bull’s eye. It relates more to zen buddhism than actual psychology.
      Now I agree it is very similar to Flow as Csíkszentmihályi described it.
      Thank you for your comment and pointing out the similarity

      • Timothy Chutes

        I hate to admit I wasn’t being mindful of what I know about zen buddhism while reading this and perhaps I would’ve picked up on your meaning more had I. So I’ve since re-read being mindful of zen and your intentional avoidance of flow.

        I’ve never liked all the requirements for flow and what I have experienced. It seems much more like what you’ve described. Flow requires clear goals, a sense of control and concentration. But now that I think about it, my mind-states more represent a state achieved through zazen meditation, letting the mind be in a state of “no-mind.”

      • Timothy Chutes

        Looks like I really should read Zen in the Art of Archery.

        • http://www.inspacewetrust.com Manuel Loigeret

          And it’s a quick read too!

  • http://mdrobertson.com Mark David Robertson

    I’d consider the Spanish ideal of “duende.” It’s like our idea of “the zone” covered in tequila and set on fire. It comes, I think, from flamenco guitarists that were playing so well that it was beyond-flawless. The last note was arbitrary–and yet we live for is the cymbal crash (the goal).

    There’s also this great line from Siddhartha: Om is the bow; the arrow is the soul, The Brahman is the arrow’s goal…the goal of the soul is to trim the fat so the Om goes right through. We’re a vessel of the Self, and this is the goal of individuation–

    Yoga gives me this feeling sometimes; other times it’s just good digestion.

    Great piece, Manu. I wish I was fluent in a non-lingual text.

    • Timothy Chutes

      But you are Mark, you’re fluent in body language.

    • http://www.inspacewetrust.com Manuel Loigeret

      Thank you Mark.
      The paradox, I think, is our need to explain this. Knowledge is not so much power after all. Ignorance and acceptance are better.
      I have to read Siddhartha.

      • Anonymous

        Siddartha is a great book. I’m quite a big fan of all herman hesse.

  • Anonymous

    “special moment in a special place where everything is aligned”

    Nice way to put it. I’m seeking this kind of alignment. I like how it happens randomly in life, but I think there are ways to encourage it. I think I shall be writing about this soon!

    • http://www.inspacewetrust.com Manuel Loigeret

      Yes, indeed… it happens most of the time randomly.
      I would like to have you point of view on this. Looking forward to your post about it.

  • http://ashokamaran.com Ashok Amaran

    Wow, I feel very connected to what you wrote. I even read that same article a few days ago on ‘what people regret just before they die.’. It’s similar to what I’ve been thinking more as the importance of a journey rather than a destination. Stopping to smell the roses. Seeing the value in the little things and not getting lost in the big things. Valuing the intangibles just as much as the tangibles. 
    “special moment in a special place where everything is aligned”. It’s sounds similar to what I’ve written about recently on my blog about the concept of the ‘Adjacent possible’. A very intriguing concept by Steven Johnson, the author of Where do Good Ideas Come From. 

    Artless Art… such a beautiful way of putting it and a metaphor for life. I feel this when I practice Yoga… and having just come back from an especially great class a couple hours ago, this resonates a little more with me right now.

    I love how you’re thinking!

    • http://www.inspacewetrust.com Manuel Loigeret

      Thank you for all the kind words Ashok. I should check Steven Johnson’s book.
      Yes I also feel that when I practice yoga, especially after a great number of sun salutations when you don’t even think you are moving and your body just moves by itself.

  • Pingback: Life into Digital Clay « Rogue Priest

  • Pingback: On time perception and boredom | In Space We Trust

  • Pilskget

    Well, just google for Depersonalization disorder, preferably the Derealization aspect of it and then you know. Everything looks like nothing.